HORSES FOR LIFE FOUNDATION
  • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • SLAUGHTER
    • Horse Slaughter
    • History of Horse Slaughter
    • Horse Slaughter Facts
    • Horse Slaughter Videos
    • Unwanted Horses Myth
  • RACING
    • HORSE DOPING
  • CRUELTY
    • Horse Soring
    • DONKEY SKIN TRADE
  • WILD HORSES
    • WILD HORSES UNDER SIEGE
    • 10 YEARS TO AML PLAN
    • KEEP PUBLIC LANDS WILD
  • ACTION ALERTS
  • NEWS + BLOG

This "Horse Traitors" Article = A Case Study of Rhetoric From Proponents of Horse Slaughter

11/1/2007

 
Source: Beef Daily
Horses are free for the asking. Sometimes they're even free without asking as unwanted horses turn up in sale barn pens, tied to someone's corral or are simply turned loose in the dead of night. Prices for horses that are trading have dropped across the spectrum because there's no longer a price floor. There's still a killer market, close to the borders. But shipping puts more miles on the horses.

Sometimes they're even free without asking as unwanted horses turn up in sale barn pens, tied to someone's corral or are simply turned loose in the dead of night. Prices for horses that are trading have dropped across the spectrum because there's no longer a price floor.

There's still a killer market, close to the borders. But shipping puts more miles on the horses and they end up at facilities in Canada and Mexico where the U.S. has no animal welfare jurisdiction.
PicturePhoto credit: Humane Society of the United States
That's what animal rights activists and others presumably concerned about the welfare of unwanted horses effectively accomplished by banning horse slaughter in this country.

“This is emotion vs. logic, and we never win those kinds of arguments,” laments Lance Baker, West Texas A&M University associate professor of animal science in the Equine Industry Program. “Most people who own horses don't treat them like livestock; they treat them more like a cross between livestock and a pet… They simply believe horsemeat should never be eaten.”

Keep in mind, this ban was accomplished through the use of state laws. In Texas, where two of the remaining three horse-slaughter plants operated until May, it was a 1949 state law originally placed on the books to prevent packers from mixing horsemeat with beef. In Illinois, it was a new state law banning the slaughter of horses for human consumption. As of Oct. 1, the courts there apparently drove the final nail into that facility's hopes by refusing its appeal.

​Pending bills in Congress could prove more worrisome to other livestock producers, though.

“We're concerned this could set a precedent that would prohibit processing of other livestock species, since the decision is based on emotion rather than on science, animal welfare and animal health,” says Josh Winegarner, Texas Cattle Feeders Association (TCFA) director of government relations.

TCFA and other state associations were heavily involved in the debate over the horse-slaughter facilities in Texas. Because the 1949 law mentioned earlier was already on the books, Winegarner explains there was little opportunity to convince slaughter-ban supporters of the unintended consequences.

In basic terms, a pending bill in the U.S. House of Representatives (H.R. 503) seeks to amend the Horse Protection Act to “…prohibit the shipping, transporting, moving, delivering, receiving, possessing, purchasing, selling, or donation of horses and other equines to be slaughtered for human consumption, and for other purposes.” A sister bill (S. 311) is pending in the Senate.

According to Brent Gattis, senior policy advisor for Olsson, Frank and Weeda, P.C. in Washington, D.C., the language in these bills is mild compared to what supporters of the slaughter ban have tried to attach via appropriations language. One version would have prohibited federal veterinary inspection of horses for all purposes. No more international trading of race horses, no more competing at international equestrian events. No more circuses with horses.

“It was unclear whether you'd even be able to move horses across state lines,” says Gattis, whose firm has been representing the processing facilities.

A letter to the chairman of the Agricultural Appropriations Committee, from 18 livestock organizations — including the American Association of Equine Practitioners (AAEP), National Cattlemen's Beef Association (NCBA), American Quarter Horse Association (AQHA) and Professional Cowboys Rodeo Association — explained the language would also prohibit inspection of live horses for disease, as well as inspections at quarantine facilities. The General Counsel for USDA's Food Safety Inspection Service and the Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service also weighed in against the language.

Tom Persechino, Horse Slaughter, AQHA
Tom Persechino of the AQHA

​“By passing this legislation, the government would be limiting the way citizens can manage their personal property,” explains Tom Persechino, senior director of marketing for the AQHA, which has fought hard against the legislation. “Horses are personal property protected under the U.S. Constitution. Any law that would result in taking of personal property without just compensation or valid purpose is a violation of an individual's constitutional rights. Furthermore, it's a violation of the Commerce Clause to unreasonably restrict interstate trade of property.”
​- Tom Persechino

Unwanted horses

Without the federal bills, life is already tougher for horses. According to a report issued by the Animal Welfare Council (AWC) last year, there are about 9.2 million horses in the U.S. (2005). Of those — previous to the ban on horse slaughter — AWC estimated about 1% (90,000 head) were marketed annually to processing for human consumption.Looking through a different glass, the total cost of caring for unwanted horses, based upon 2005 statistics, is $220 million/year, according to AWC. Persechino also shares AAEP statistics that estimate basic sustenance horse care at $1,900/horse/year — feed, water and shelter but no veterinary or farrier expense.

None of the expenses account for the lost processing revenue, either.

“Those in favor of banning horse slaughter say those 90,000 head can be absorbed into current horse-rescue facilities,” Baker says. “First, no federal regulations exist to govern the care of horses in those facilities. Second, there aren't enough rescue facilities to take care of 90,000 unwanted horses this year, let alone another 80,000-90,000 the year after that, and so on.”
​
“There are very few, and by that I mean less than a handful of, publicly funded, equine facilities/shelters like those in every city for dogs and cats,” Persechino explains. “If the government is going to limit processing as an option, they should first provide economic alternatives for owners. Dog and cat shelters enjoy widespread public support and funding. Shouldn't horses have the same option?”
In a paper entitled “The Unintended Consequences of a Ban on the Humane Slaughter of Horses in the U.S.,” AWC explains, “For all disposal methods, except for onsite burial, transportation of the horse carcass to the disposal site creates issues pertaining to cost, disease transmission and potential exposure to the public of deceased animals. The increasing cost and difficulty of carcass disposal is emerging as a significant issue for horse owners with limited financial capacity to care for an unwanted horse.”
When renderers are available, they charge $75-$250. There's incineration, but it's not necessarily readily available, and it costs $600-$2,000, AWC says. Newer technologies like composting and bio-degradation also come at a cost and have unique environmental or access challenges. Even burial — euthanization by a veterinarian and disposal at a certified landfill still willing to accept horse carcasses — will cost $300-$500.

What's more, Baker points to the sad but well-known cases of dogs and cats abandoned by their owners out in the country, rather than taken to the local animal shelter, many of which charge nothing. He wonders what would possess such people to pay for humane euthanasia and disposal of an unwanted horse. “Without the option and economic incentive to process horses, the number of animal-neglect cases may double or triple in local communities,” AWC concludes.

That was the basis of a joint response from NCBA and 190 other organizations to the pending federal bills: “…As many as 90,000 horses annually will need care, food and shelter. S. 311, and legislation in the House, H.R. 503, both fail to address the problems of costs for care and the unintended mistreatment of these animals in non-regulated rescue facilities.”

Persechino says, “I think you also can expect taxpayers to foot the bill for horses that become part of the ‘equine welfare’ system, just as we are currently subsidizing wild mustangs and burros.”

​Still time to fight
​

Ironically, Winegarner points out it may become easier to get the public and their elected officials to recognize the problem with unwanted horses in light of the ban on horse slaughter as more horses are abandoned and neglected.

“Continue to educate your representatives in Congress about any impacts you see from the ban on horse slaughter, and about the unintended consequences it could have on other livestock species,” advises Winegarner.

“This is a good example of what animal-rights groups such as the Humane Society of the United States are willing to do in their effort to prohibit anyone from owning livestock for any reason,” Gattis says. “It's also a good example of what can happen unless the agricultural industry bands together.”
    Picture

    TOPICS

    +  Horse Slaughter
    ​

    +  Horse Racing

    ​​+  WILD HORSES

    +  Horse Soring

    +  Donkey Skin Trade

    ​CATEGORIES

    SUBJECTS

    All
    10 Years To AML
    1971 Free Roaming Wild Horse And Burro Act
    AAEP
    AB 128
    Adopt Don't Shop
    Ag Gag
    Agriculture Appropriations
    Allen Rutberg
    American Mustang Foundation
    American Quarter Horse Association
    American Slaughter Prevention Act
    Andy Barr
    Animal Abuse
    Animal Cruelty
    Animal Law
    Animal Welfare Act
    Appropriations Committee
    AQHA
    Assateague
    AUM
    Beef Belt
    Ben Shelly
    Bible Spring Complex
    Big Lick
    Bill Richardson
    Blair Dunn
    BLM
    Boyd Spratling
    Brian Sandoval
    Bruce Wagman
    Bruce Wagman
    Bureau Of Land Management
    Burros
    Canada
    Canadian Horse Defence Coalition
    CFIA
    Chevaline
    Chris Stewart
    Churchill Downs
    Clean Racing
    Congressional Veterinary Medicine Caucus
    Corolla Wild Horses
    Corolla Wild Horses Protection Act
    D'Allende Meats
    Dan Erdel
    David Bernhardt
    David Rains
    Deerwood Ranch
    Dianne Feinstein
    Dina Titus
    Disaster Planning
    Donkey
    Donkey Skins
    Dorian Ayache
    Double D Ranch
    Earl Blumenauer
    Eco Sanctuary
    Ed Whitfield
    Ejiao
    Emergency Evacuations
    Endangered Species Act
    Epa
    Equine Information Document
    European Commission
    Farm Bill
    Fda
    Feral Horses
    Fertility Control
    Fish And Wildlife Service
    Fmia
    Food Fraud
    Food Safety
    Forest Service
    Foundation To Protect New Mexico Wildlife
    Frank Guinta
    FSIS
    GAO
    Gary Herbert
    Gary King
    Genetic Viability
    Giving Tuesday
    GnRH
    Goicoechea
    GonaCon
    Grazing Improvement Act
    Grazing Permits
    Horse Abuse
    Horse Care
    Horse Carriages
    Horse Doping
    Horsemeat
    Horse Protection Act
    Horseracing
    Horse Racing
    Horseracing Integrity Act
    Horseracing Integrity And Safety Act
    Horse Rescue
    Horses
    Horses For Life Foundation
    Horse Slaughter
    Horse Soring
    Horse Transport
    Horse Transportation Safety Act
    Horse Tripping
    Horse Whipping
    H.R.1518
    Hr 1518
    H.R. 1942
    H.R. 5058
    HSUS
    Humane Methods Of Slaughter Act
    Humboldt
    Interior Appropriations
    International Equine Business Association
    Iowa
    Iron-county
    Jan Schakowsky
    Jay Nixon
    Jim Moran
    Joan Guilfoyle
    Jockey Club
    Joe Neguse
    John-barrasso
    John Katko
    Johnnie HMA
    Joseph D. Tydings
    Judy Chu
    Kansas
    Karen Budd-Falen
    Keaton Walker
    Ken Salazar
    Kentucky Derby
    King Amendment
    Kurt Schrader
    Larry Wheelon
    Lasix
    L.D. 1286
    Leonard Blach
    Lester Friedlander
    Lisa Murkowski
    Livestock
    Maine
    Mary Fallin
    Mary Landrieu
    Matt Mead
    Mexico
    Michelle Lujan Grisham
    Mike Fitzpatrick
    Mike Lee
    Missouri
    Mitt Romney
    Modoc
    Moran Young Amendment
    Moranyoung Amendment670e4071a7
    Mowdy Ranch
    NACO
    National Academy Of Sciences
    National Day Of The Horse
    National Residue Program
    Navajo Nation
    Neil Kornze
    NEPA
    Nevada
    New Mexico
    New Mexico Equine Rescue Alliance
    Nicholas Dodman
    Nm
    North Carolina
    NTRA
    OGF Vaccine
    Oklahoma
    Oocyte Growth Factor Vaccine
    Oregon
    Ottb
    PAST ACT
    Path Forward Plan
    Patricia M. Fazio
    Patrick Meehan
    Paul Tonko
    PEER
    Phenylbutazon
    Platero Project
    Porcine Zona Pelucida
    Princess Anne
    Public Lands
    Public Lands Council
    PZP
    Rains Natural Meats
    Raul Grijalva
    Responsible Transportation
    Richard-burr
    Rick De Los Santos
    Robert Redford
    Roly Owers
    Rosa DeLauro
    Roswell
    Roy Blunt
    Roy Blunt
    Ryan Zinke
    Ryoichi Okubo
    SAFE Act
    SAFE Act
    Safeguard American Food Exports Act
    Sage Grouse
    Sally Jewell
    Sally Jewell
    Santa Anita
    SB 469
    Science-and-conservation-center
    Sooner Poll
    Soring
    South-korea
    Spayvac
    Sterilization
    Steve King
    Steve-king
    Stronarch-group
    Susanamartinez
    Susana Martinez
    Susana Martinez
    Tail-braces
    Taylor-grazing-act
    Ted-yoho
    Tennessee-walking-horses
    Tennessee-walking-horses
    Theodore-roosevelt-national-park
    Theresa-vincent
    Todd-gloria
    Tom Davis
    Tom Gorey
    Tom-gorey
    Tom-persechino
    Tom-udall
    Tom Vilsack
    Tom Vilsack
    Tribal Lands
    Unwanted-horses
    Usada
    Us Court Of Appealsd83cbed7a8
    USDA
    Us Fish And Wildlife Service86af631d0b
    Us Forest Service367fe28759
    Usgs
    Utah
    Valley Meat
    Valley Meat
    Vern-buchanan
    Vern-buchanan
    Voluntary-grazing-permit-retirement-act
    Walking Horses
    Walter-b-jones
    Welfare-ranchers
    Western-watersheds-project
    Whip Rules
    Wild Horses
    Wild-oversight-act
    William-perry-pendley
    World-horse-welfare
    Wyoming
    Yakama Nation
    Yakama-nation
    Yakama-nation
    Zonastath

    ​ARCHIVES

    MONTH / yEAR

    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    October 2017
    September 2017
    May 2017
    September 2016
    June 2016
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    February 2012
    December 2011
    June 2011
    July 2008
    November 2007

Picture

WHO WE ARE

About Us
Contact Us

COMMUNITY

Facebook
Twitter

LATEST NEWS

Horse Slaughter
Horse Racing
Wild Horses
Horse Soring

RESOURCES

Unwanted Horses Myth
Adopt Don't Shop
Adoption Tips

​THIS WEBSITE AND ITS CONTENT COPYRIGHT OF HORSES FOR LIFE FOUNDATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. © 2012—2021

  • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • SLAUGHTER
    • Horse Slaughter
    • History of Horse Slaughter
    • Horse Slaughter Facts
    • Horse Slaughter Videos
    • Unwanted Horses Myth
  • RACING
    • HORSE DOPING
  • CRUELTY
    • Horse Soring
    • DONKEY SKIN TRADE
  • WILD HORSES
    • WILD HORSES UNDER SIEGE
    • 10 YEARS TO AML PLAN
    • KEEP PUBLIC LANDS WILD
  • ACTION ALERTS
  • NEWS + BLOG