Horses For Life
  • Home
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • WILD HORSES
  • Horse Slaughter
    • Horse Slaughter Facts
    • History of Horse Slaughter
    • Why Ban Horse Slaughter?
    • Horse Slaughter Videos
  • ACTION ALERTS
  • ADOPT | RESCUE
  • NEWS | BLOG

Horse Slaughter Lawsuit Cites FSIS Failure To Follow NEPA Requirements 

10/10/2013

 
An agency within the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) lacks discretion to deny requests to inspect horse slaughter facilities if they meet requirements under the Federal Meat Inspection Act, rendering an environmental review essentially meaningless, government lawyers argue.
Horse Slaughter
Citing the failure of the Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) to follow the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), animal welfare groups—including Front Range Equine Rescue, Horses for Life Foundation and Humane Society of the United States among others—have sued the agency in federal court.

The lawsuit has at least temporarily thwarted the plans of three facilities in Iowa, Missouri and New Mexico to slaughter horses for human consumption. The controversial practice has infuriated animal rights groups and divided Native American tribes. 

In a brief filed last month, Justice Department lawyers argue NEPA doesn't apply to its horse slaughter oversight because FSIS lacks the authority to impose environmental conditions or deny a proposal for inspection on environmental grounds. 

Since federal law requires FSIS to grant inspections to facilities that meet eligibility requirements under the Federal Meat Inspection Act, "environmental considerations pursuant to a NEPA analysis could not have changed FSIS' decision," the government lawyers wrote.

The animal rights groups that have sued FSIS vigorously disagree, and a federal judge is leaning in their favor. In temporary restraining orders that enjoin FSIS from dispatching inspectors to the horse slaughter facilities, Chief U.S. District Judge Christine Armijo has found plaintiffs are likely to prevail on their claims. The judge is expected to make her final decision—whether to grant a permanent injunction—by the end of October. A final ruling is likely to be challenged before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit.

Horse Slaughter
Plaintiffs have challenged FSIS's decisions to grant inspections and a directive that relates to a drug residue testing program for equines. FSIS Directive 6130.1 provides instructions to government personnel on how to inspect horses before and after they are slaughtered, including instructions for drug residue testing.

In the lawsuit, plaintiffs cite a number of environmental hazards associated with horse slaughter facilities before three plants closed six years ago.

"As described in the record, individuals in the vicinity of previous horse slaughter plants were forced to endure a noxious stench, dealt with blood in streams, and sometimes even found blood and horse tissue running through their water faucets," plaintiffs wrote in a brief.

"Whether this will happen again is precisely the question that should be explored in a properly prepared NEPA document."

NEPA

NEPA typically requires federal agencies to assess the environmental consequences of a proposed action through an "environmental assessment" (EA) and/or a more comprehensive "environmental impact statement" (EIS). FSIS has
conducted neither an EA nor an EIS in connection with the horse slaughter facilities or the agency's drug residue testing program. 

NEPA's requirements don't apply to a federal agency if a proposed action will not have a "significant" impact either individually or cumulatively on the human environment. Regulations excuse FSIS from preparing an EA or EIS unless the agency's administrator, Al Almanza, decides "an action may have a significant environmental effect," according to a memo from FSIS that granted federal meat inspection services to Roswell, N.M.-based Valley Meat Company, LLC.

FSIS's action "is purely ministerial" since it must grant federal inspection if a facility has met statutory and regulatory requirements, the agency concluded in the June 27 memo.  "A grant of federal inspection likewise does not and will not allow FSIS to exercise sufficient control over the commercial horse slaughter activities at Valley Meat such that the grant will constitute a major federal action that triggers NEPA requirements," the memo declared.

The agency explained it only has authority to regulate a facility to the extent necessary to verify that meat produced for human consumption is properly labeled, packaged and wholesome.

Drug Residues

Plaintiffs have expressed fears that the horse slaughter plants are potentially dangerous in part because drugs that are administered to horses are not safe for human consumption and have the potential to contaminate "local ecosystems and water and soil supplies."

Between 1996 and 2006, when FSIS tested horses for drugs before funding for horse inspections was withdrawn, few equines tested positive, according to the agency. But plaintiffs contend FSIS failed to test the animals for many drugs that are commonly administered to horses.
Horsemeat
Documents submitted to the federal government have listed 115 drugs and categories of drugs that have been approved for use in horses and have been known to cause problems for humans, according to Bruce Wagman, an attorney representing a number of plaintiffs in the lawsuit.

The Attorney General of New Mexico has expressed similar fears, pointing out in a letter to Valley Meat that horse meat containing such dangerous substances as the anti-inflammatory drug phenylbutazone (PBZ) would be considered "adulterated" in violation of state law.

FSIS has defended the drug testing program, citing a number of safeguards—including random tests of horses after they are slaughtered—that are intended to protect the public from exposure to harmful chemicals and pesticide residues.

State agencies and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) investigate companies whose meat has tested positive for unpermitted drug residues, and FDA has authority to prosecute a business and take other enforcement action, FSIS pointed out.

Although FSIS has acknowledged it will conduct fewer samples under its new program, the agency said it will analyze them for a larger number of chemical compounds. But plaintiffs gripe the new program "ignores several dozen other substances commonly given to horses that may be harmful to humans."

Source: Food Product Design by Josh Long


Help Make Horse Slaughter Illegal in the United States! Contact Congress in support of the SAFE Act. Passage of the SAFE Act will not only ensure that predatory horse slaughterers cannot reopen their doors here in the U.S.— it will also stop the trafficking of  horses to slaughterhouses over American borders. Click Here to Take Action!

Comments are closed.

    RSS Feed

    Picture

    Author

    Horses For Life Foundation is dedicated to ending the slaughter of American horses, preserving and protecting the wild horses and burros on public lands, and ending horse abuse and neglect through Advocacy, Public Education, and Policy Reform.

    Tweets by @_HorsesForLife

    Archives

    May 2015
    April 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    June 2011

    Picture
    >>> View Current ACTION ALERTS

    Categories

    All
    1971 Free Roaming Wild Horse And Burro Act
    AAEP
    Action Alert
    Ag Gag
    Agriculture Appropriations
    Agriculture-appropriations
    Aldf
    American Wild Horse Preservation Campaign
    Animal Abuse
    Animal-abuse
    Animal Cruelty
    Animal-cruelty
    Animal Law
    Animal-law
    Animal Legal Defense Fund
    Animal-protection-of-new-mexico
    Animal Welfare Act
    Animal Welfare Institute
    Appropriations Committee
    Appropriations-committee
    Aspca
    Assateague
    AUM
    Beef-belt-llc
    Ben Shelly
    Ben-shelly
    Bible-spring-complex
    Big Lick
    Big-lick
    Bill Richardson
    Bill-richardson
    Blair Dunn
    Blair-dunn
    Blm
    Boyd Spratling
    Brian Sandoval
    Bruce Wagman
    Bruce-wagman
    Bureau Of Land Management
    Burros
    Canada
    Cfia
    Chevaline
    Chris Stewart
    Cloud Foundation
    Corolla Wild Horses
    Corolla-wild-horses-protection-act
    D'Allende Meats
    Dan-erdel
    David Rains
    David-rains
    Deerwood Ranch
    Disaster Planning
    Donkey
    Dorian-ayache
    Double D Ranch
    Eco Sanctuary
    Ed Whitfield
    Ed-whitfield
    Emergency Evacuations
    Endangered Species Act
    Epa
    Equine Information Document
    European Commission
    Farm Bill
    Fda
    Feral Horses
    Fertility Control
    Fish And Wildlife Service
    Fmia
    Food Safety
    Food-safety
    Forest Service
    Foundation To Protect New Mexico Wildlife
    Foundation-to-protect-new-mexico-wildlife
    Frank Guinta
    Front Range Equine Rescue
    Front-range-equine-rescue
    Fsis
    Gary Herbert
    Gary King
    Gary-king
    Genetic Viability
    Giving Tuesday
    GnRH
    GonaCon
    Grazing Improvement Act
    Grazing Permits
    Horse Abuse
    Horse-abuse
    Horse Care
    Horse-care
    Horse Carriages
    Horsemeat
    Horse Protection Act
    Horse-protection-act
    Horse Racing
    Horse-racing
    Horseracing Integrity And Safety Act
    Horseracing-integrity-and-safety-act
    Horse Rescue
    Horse-rescue
    Horses
    Horses For Life Foundation
    Horse Slaughter
    Horse-slaughter
    Horse Soring
    Horse Transport
    Horse-transport
    Horse Transportation Safety Act
    Horse-transportation-safety-act
    Horse Tripping
    Hr 1518
    Hr 1518ac88d1315d
    H.R. 1942
    H.R. 5058
    HSUS
    Humane Methods Of Slaughter Act
    Humane Society International
    Humboldt
    International Equine Business Association
    Iowa
    Iron-county
    Jan Schakowsky
    Jan-schakowsky
    Jay-nixon
    Jim Moran
    Jim-moran
    Joan Guilfoyle
    Joanna Swabe
    John Barrasso
    Johnnie HMA
    Kansas
    Karen Budd-Falen
    Keaton Walker
    Ken Salazar
    King Amendment
    Ld 12861fa1b5a140
    Leonard Blach
    Lester Friedlander
    Livestock
    Maine
    Mary Fallin
    Mary Landrieu
    Mary-landrieu
    Matt Mead
    Mexico
    Michelle Lujan Grisham
    Michelle-lujan-grisham
    Mike Fitzpatrick
    Missouri
    Moran Young Amendment
    Moran-young-amendment
    Moranyoung Amendment670e4071a7
    Mowdy Ranch
    NACO
    National Academy Of Sciences
    National Day Of The Horse
    National Residue Program
    Navajo Nation
    Navajo-nation
    Neil Kornze
    NEPA
    Nevada
    New Mexico
    New-mexico
    New Mexico Equine Rescue Alliance
    Nicholas Dodman
    Nm
    North-carolina
    Oklahoma
    Ottb
    Past Act
    Past-act
    Patricia M. Fazio
    Patrick Meehan
    Patrick-meehan
    PEER
    Phenylbutazon
    Platero Project
    Porcine Zona Pelucida
    Princess Anne
    Public Lands
    PZP
    Rains Natural Meats
    Rains-natural-meats
    Raul Grijalva
    Responsible Transportation
    Richard-burr
    Rick De Los Santos
    Rick-de-los-santos
    Roly Owers
    Rosa DeLauro
    Roswell
    Roy Blunt
    Roy-blunt
    Ryoichi Okubo
    SAFE Act
    SAFE Act
    Sage Grouse
    Sally Jewell
    Sally Jewell
    Science And Conservation Center
    Sooner Poll
    Soring
    SpayVac
    Sterilization
    Steve King
    Susana Martinez
    Susana-martinez
    Taylor Grazing Act
    Theodore Roosevelt National Park
    Theresa-vincent
    Tom Davis
    Tom Gorey
    Tom Gorey
    Tom Udall
    Tom-udall
    Tom Vilsack
    Tom Vilsack
    Tribal Lands
    Tribal-lands
    Us Court Of Appealsd83cbed7a8
    USDA
    Us Fish And Wildlife Service86af631d0b
    Us Forest Service367fe28759
    USGS
    Utah
    Valley Meat
    Valley-meat
    Vern Buchanan
    Walking Horses
    Walking-horses
    Walter-b-jones
    Welfare Ranchers
    Western-watersheds-project
    Wild Horse Education
    Wild Horse Oversight Act
    Wild Horses
    Wild-horses
    World-horse-welfare
    Wyoming
    Yakama Nation
    Yakama-nation

© 2012 -- 2018 Horses For Life Foundation. All rights reserved.
✕